I'm going to New York in a few weeks, and this shop is right at the top of my list. Kill Devil Hill is a destination shop, conveniently located near the Brooklyn Flea market. I have it on good authority too: Kill Devil Hill was recently named one of the best six new stores in America by The New York Times. The owners Mary Brockman and Mark Straiton find their stock on road trips around America - there's an interview with them in New York Magazine here.
Photos via Apartment Therapy.